| Rank | Show Title |
|---|---|
| 1. | I Love Lucy
 |
| 2. | Arthur Godfrey's Talent Scouts |
| 3. | You Bet Your Life |
| 4. | Dragnet |
| 5. | Fireside Theater |
| 6. | The Jack Benny Show |
| 7. | Ford Theater |
| 8. | Texaco Star Theater |
| 9. | The Red Skelton Show |
| 10. | Arthur Godfrey and His Friends |
| 11. | GE Theater |
| 12. | Colgate Comedy Hour |
| 13. | Mama |
| 14. | Gillette Cavalcade of Sports |
| 15. | $64,000 Question |
| 16. | December Bride |
| 17. | I've Got a Secret |
| 18. | The Millionaire |
| 19. | Your Show of Shows |
| 20. | The Perry Como Show |
